Skip to content
Skip to product information
Mystery Box
Mystery Box
Mystery Box
Description

 

Who doesn't love a good surprise.

Find a selection of amazing & different flavours in a mystery box.
Each box contains 12 cookies (6 pairs) that are heat sealed in pairs, allowing for an extended shelf life of 9 months. Store in a cool dry place.

This product may consist of a variety of gourmet flavours, discontinued flavours & mainstream flavours. 

PLEASE NOTE: Mystery boxes are not able to be customized to exclude certain products eg. nuts, fruit etc. Please ensure that you are happy for a wide variety of flavours & do not have any allergens when selecting this product.

(image is for display purpose and does not reflect the contents of the mystery box you will receive.)

Mystery Box

Regular price $31.95

Tax included. Shipping calculated at checkout

Order before 12pm for same day dispatch

Money Back Guarantee

Free shipping over $150

 

Who doesn't love a good surprise.

Find a selection of amazing & different flavours in a mystery box.
Each box contains 12 cookies (6 pairs) that are heat sealed in pairs, allowing for an extended shelf life of 9 months. Store in a cool dry place.

This product may consist of a variety of gourmet flavours, discontinued flavours & mainstream flavours. 

PLEASE NOTE: Mystery boxes are not able to be customized to exclude certain products eg. nuts, fruit etc. Please ensure that you are happy for a wide variety of flavours & do not have any allergens when selecting this product.

(image is for display purpose and does not reflect the contents of the mystery box you will receive.)

Mystery Box
Regular price $31.95

Same Day Dispatch before 12pm

Free Shipping over $150

Gift Milky Goodness

Money Back Guarantee

Overall rating: 4.8985505 / 5 from 69 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Mystery Box offers a delightful surprise with a variety of gourmet, discontinued, and mainstream cookie flavors. Customers appreciate the delicious taste and the wide selection of flavors, though they should be aware that the contents cannot be customized.

Summary topics

  • Flavor Variety: 20%
  • Taste Quality: 56%

Review topics: [].

Review highlights

  • "I really enjoyed this box as a way to try different flavours and the surprise was fun too." — Abi
  • "The mystery box is a great way to sample different cookie flavours." — Julieane
  • "Love the variety and taste!" — Suhailah

Reviews

I can’t believe how delicious

"I can’t believe how delicious these are. I have definitely seen an increase in my supply which gives me such good peace of mind that I can continue to feed my little one."

— L K. (5/5)

My fourth baby, and I’ve

"My fourth baby, and I’ve used Milky Goodness for three of them — so ordering again this time was a no brainer. I grabbed a mystery box a few days before bub arrived and started having one cookie a day to prep. My little boy ended up arriving early and is currently in NICU, so pumping has been such a big part of my days. Once again, I’m blown away. I’m pumping every few hours and the volume I’m getting has surprised even the midwives. It’s given me so much comfort knowing I can provide for him during this time. And honestly, the cookies are so good (which matters when you’re exhausted and living in trackies). The mystery box was such a fun mix too. I’ll always come back 🤍"

— Renay F. (5/5)

Love the variety in these

"Love the variety in these boxes and not having to pick. There are so many great tasting cookies and I love having a selection of them at hand. Haven’t eaten one I haven’t enjoyed and noticed a boost in my supply since using Milky Goodness."

— Nicole W. (5/5)

Nice selection

"I got a few duplicates but besides that I'm happy that I get to try different flavours"

— Izzy (4/5)

Excellent

"It gives you a good taste of everything to help choose what’s your best and if your hard of deciding get the mixture box you taste a bit of everything"

— taylah h. (5/5)

Taste amazing and the supply is bumping!

"I had tried other lactation cookies but they made my little one so extremely gassy she was inconsolable and supply wasn’t helped as much as I hoped. As soon as I had these my supply doubled! Baby girl was soo much happier in her belly as well. We live for these biscuits when we feed it’s our little ritual. Supply went up to 150ml one side. Thank you soo much!"

— Aeisha (5/5)

These cookies taste amazing!! My

"These cookies taste amazing!! My favourite being the m&ms. Definitely recommend and would purchase again."

— Jessica P. (5/5)

Great for when you can’t

"Great for when you can’t make your mind up on what you want to try!"

— Anastasia M. (5/5)

So good!

"This box is such a great way to try different flavours!"

— Rachel (5/5)

Yum!

"Love the mystery box. I was a first time customer and couldn't decide on a flavour so give this a go. A really great combination of flavours. The white chocolate and Nutella was soooo yummy. Will definitely try a mystery box aahin in the future so I have variation. I also found a couple of days after trying the cookies that my milk production has really improved."

— Jaimie (5/5)

Q&A

Copyright© 2026 Milky Goodness Powered by Shopify

  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Union Pay
  • Visa
Drawer Title
Similar Products